I don't wear eyeliner day to day, but I liked the colors in this 2 in 1. Knowing full and well that creamy eyeshadow products aren't my favorite, I bought it anyway in the shade brown/basic. The colors are nice, they apply fairly easily. But if they are touched even slightly, all the pigment rubs off immediately. What's left of the shadow is a lot of sparkly shimmer and the eyeliner leaves a faint line. Like everything else, used with a primer and setting with a powder helps. But even as a base, it's not worth the trouble for me.
*Edited to add pictures taken with new camera, still lousy lighting. One thing at a time!